The Gandhi Nobody Knows – 1

May 8, 2006 at 10:07 pm 3 comments

Many historians and experts object strenuously that the picture of Gandhi that emerges in the movie or for that matter the Indian history books, is grossly inaccurate, omitting, as one of many examples, that when Gandhi’s wife lay dying of pneumonia and British doctors insisted that a shot of penicillin would save her, Gandhi refused to have this alien medicine injected in her body and simply let her die. It must be noted that when Gandhi contracted malaria shortly afterward he accepted for himself the alien medicine quinine, and that when he had appendicitis he allowed British doctors to perform on him the alien outrage of an appendectomy.
The government of India openly admits to having provided one-third of the financing of ‘Gandhi’ out of state funds, straight out of the national treasury–and after close study of the finished product experts would not be a bit surprised to hear that it was 100 percent. If Pandit Nehru is portrayed flatteringly in the film, one must remember that Nehru himself took part in the initial story conferences (he originally wanted Gandhi to be played by Alec Guinness) and that his daughter Indira Gandhi is, after all, Prime Minister of India (though no relation to Mohandas Gandhi). The screenplay was checked and rechecked by Indian officials at every stage, often by the Prime Minister herself, with close consultations on plot and even casting. If the movie contains a particularly poisonous portrait of Mohammed Ali Jinnah, the founder of Pakistan, the Indian reply, would be that if the Pakistanis want an attractive portrayal of Jinnah let them pay for their own movie. Someone, highly sophisticated in political matters but innocent about film-making, declared that ‘Gandhi’ should be preceded by the legend: *The following film is a paid political advertisement by the government of India.*

“Gandhi”, then, is a large, pious, historical morality tale centered on a saintly, sanitized Mahatma Gandhi cleansed of anything too embarrassingly Hindu (the word “caste” is not mentioned from one end of the film to the other) and, indeed, of most of the rest of Gandhi’s life, much of which would drastically diminish his saintliness in Western eyes. There is little to indicate that the India of today has followed Gandhi’s precepts in almost nothing. There is little, in fact, to indicate that India is even India. The spectator realizes the scene is the Indian subcontinent because there are thousands of extras dressed in dhotis and saris. The characters go about talking in these quaint Peter Sellers accents. We have occasional shots of India’s holy poverty, holy hovels, some landscapes, many of them photographed quite beautifully, for those who like travelogues. We have a character called Lord Mountbatten (India’s last Viceroy); a composite American journalist (assembled >from Vincent Sheehan, William L. Shirer, Louis Fischer, and straight fiction); a character called simply “Viceroy” (presumably another composite); an assemblage of Gandhi’s Indian followers under the name of one of them (Patel); and of course Nehru.

Not a single Indian history book talks about Gandhi’s pretty teenage girl followers fighting “hysterically” (the word was used) for the honor of sleeping naked with the Mahatma and cuddling the
nude septuagenarian in their arms. (Gandhi was “testing” his vow of chastity in order to gain moral strength for his mighty struggle with Jinnah.) When told there was a man named Freud who said that, despite his declared intention, Gandhi might actually be *enjoying* the caresses of the naked girls, Gandhi continued, unperturbed. Gandhi daily used to give enemas to all the young girls in his ashrams (his daily greeting was, “Have you had a good bowel movement this morning, sisters?”). Although Gandhi seems to have written less about home rule for India than he did about enemas, and excrement, and latrine cleaning (“The bathroom is a temple. It should be so clean and inviting that anyone would enjoy eating there”).

To be continued…

[From the magazine, “Commentary,” March 1983, published monthly by the American Jewish Committee, New York, NY.]


Entry filed under: Inside stories.

SOLO The Gandhi Nobody Knows – 2

3 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Bindu  |  May 10, 2006 at 2:39 pm

    It sucks.. Better you dont write PART TWO…

    You are almost making me puke at this fellow’s nature.. However, you really have to agree.. that this guy had a role in freedom struggle…

    Can’t deny it.. can u?

  • 2. Anand  |  August 22, 2006 at 6:54 pm

    Those who with no or little knowledge of gandhi would accept Richard’s remarks as the common mass always looking for stigamas attached to great people just as in the case of Osho Rajaneesh. His article is fraught with inaccuracies and one who believe in him would be in effect cheating the history.

  • 3. Bruce  |  September 5, 2010 at 7:19 pm

    Outside of the elitist liberal arena Gandi’s life is well known, even if he was the prophet of non violence, much blood was shed in around him, but it does not take away from his achievements in Indian history whatever that may have been, his life was what it was, we cannot take away from truth, but he has like John Lennon become an image for peace that we as South Africans are very grateful for, Nelson Mandela in a great sense was a product of Gandi, and that saved our nation, so viva Mandela viva and viva Gandi viva


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


  • RT @beeonaposy: Jumping back into code you wrote ages ago like 10% luck 20% skill 15% concentrated power of will 5% pleasure… 2 weeks ago
  • RT @jimmysong: Stuff CS departments should teach, but don't do very well: * Source control, esp. git * How to do effective code review * H… 1 month ago
  • RT @farbodsaraf: Advice to new managers: 1 earn trust by giving it 2 hire for EQ, train for IQ 3 eat lunch with your team 4 tell people t… 1 month ago


%d bloggers like this: